With Statement in C# .Net

If you’re stumbling across this article, chances are you may be looking for a replacement for VB .Net’s “with” statement.

Sadly, there is no exact replacement, but there are alternatives which are equally helpful.

Given a basic class “Robot” below:

public class Robot {
public string name {get;set;}
public int age {get;set;}

Variable Declaration

If you were using “With” simply for initial variable declaration so you didn’t have to specify long constructors, you can use the following instead:

public Robot MyRobot = new Robot() {name="Ronnie-5", age=3300};

If you were using “With” to stay within the context of an object while performing a specific task, then there is no direct equivalent, although I would definitely advise you to try “using” if you’re not already.

using (Robot MyRobot = new MyRobot()) {

if (MyRobot.name=="something") {
//do something
//when finished it will automatically dispose for you

Extension Methods

Another approach, if your concern is code readability and brevity is to begin using some generic class extension methods in your project to help you simplify common tasks. (see example below)

(Kudos to Anay Kamat for clean and reusable code.)

public static class MetaExtensions
	public static void Set(this object obj,params Func<string,object>[] hash){
			foreach(Func<string,object> member in hash){
				var propertyName = member.Method.GetParameters()[0].Name;
				var propertyValue = member(string.Empty);

So you could also alternatively replace “With” by adding the above class extension method and simply doing:

var myrobot = new Robot();
	name=> "Ronnie-5",
	age=> 3300

//or as a one-liner


Now this is technically more lines of code than simply declaring initialization values in the first code snippet, but the upside is… well actually, I’m not sure of the upside, but it’s definitely cool. 🙂

Anay Kamat (blog), http://anaykamat.com/2009/08/09/simple-equivalent-of-with-statement-in-c-sharp/
MSDN (Extension Methods), http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/bb383977.aspx


About Ronnie Diaz

Ronnie Diaz is a software engineer and tech consultant. Ronnie started his career in front-end and back-end development for companies in ecommerce, service industries and remote education. This work transitioned from traditional desktop client-server applications through early cloud development. Software included human resource management and service technician workflows, online retail e-commerce and electronic ordering and fulfillment, IVR customer relational systems, and video streaming remote learning SCORM web applications. Hands on server experience and software performance optimization led to creation of a startup business focused on collocated data center services and continued experience with video streaming hardware and software. This led to a career in Amazon Prime Video where Ronnie is currently employed, building software and systems which stream live sports and events for millions of viewers around the world.

Posted on May 6, 2011, in Programming & Development and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Leave a comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: